View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. It raises the debate about laws role in a globalised world order to a completely new level. We shall now turn to what marx and engels have said about equality before law and equal rights. A marxist theory of international law historical materialism books haymarket books first edition by china mieville isbn. It is not for nothing, after all, that after publishing between equal rights mieville has more or less stopped writing about international law. A marxist theory of international law brill leiden 2005. A marxist theory of international law historical materialism new ed by mieville, china isbn. In this particular essay pashukanis seems successfully to have accommodated himself to the fact that the legal. Even many individuals might not like checking out publications. Between equal rights a marxist theory of international law brill.
Armed with this marxist approach, he is able to explain why international law is law, despite the lack of an armed authority above the worlds states to enforce it, which is a big theoretical dilemma that bourgeois political science majors and specialists in the field of international relations. A marxist theory of international law historical materialism mieville, china on. It draws on the jurisprudence of evgeny pashukanis linking law to commodity exchange, and in turn uses international law as an optic through which to make better sense of pashukanis general theory. A marxist theory of international law by china mieville, legal studies, 27 2. Indeed, marxist theory overlaps with much of the current work within critical theories of law, such as radical feminism and. Mieville has said he plans to write a novel in every genre. A marxist theory of international law has its origin as china mievilles doctoral dissertation in international relations. A marxist theory of international law brill 2005 54. Between equal rights a marxist theory of international law. It constructs an alternative marxist approach, and argues that imperialism is intrinsic to international law. This is reflected in an upsurge in scholarship dealing with international laws relationship to imperial power and its progressive potential. International judicial activism and the commodity form theory of. Marxist law marxist legal theory is grounded in a denial of the existence of god and a belief that we and our social systems are evolving.
There has also been an increase in the number of marxist accounts of international law, with china mievilles between equal rights being particularly important. A marxist theory of international law brill, historical materialism book. In marx s classless society there will be no individual rights which will limit the freedom of others. A marxist theory of international law leiden and boston. A marxist theory of international law, by china mieville. We have waited a long time for a comprehensive and progressive critique of international law. The candidates can usefully be ranked by their apparent relative concreteness. Pdf marxist approaches to international law robert knox. The riddle of all constitutions offers a remarkably effective illustration of the classical marxist project of ideology critique as applied in a traditional international law context. A marxist theory of international law by china mieville is a sharp and deftly presented leftist critique of international law from the sixteenth century to the present day. It is the most comprehensive scholarly account available of the central theoretical debates about the foundations of international law. Pashukanis essay the marxist theory of law and the construction of socialism appeared in the subsequent issue, and was directed as a reply both to stuchka and to the swelling criticism of his own followers in the communist academy. First, a marxist approach to international law is inextri cably related to its theory of international relations whose essence is in the final analysis determined by the mannerin which states are internally organised. International law today creates and congeals inequities in the international system.
In the former, he demonstrated that it was possible, on the basis of the. Marxism, international law, and political strategy leiden. Enlightenment, understood in the widest sense as the advance of thought, has always aimed at liberating. The theory of socialproperty relations, or political marxism, has argued that in contradistinction with precapitalist forms of exploitation, capitalism is characterised by the separation of the economic and the political, which makes surplus appropriation under this system uniquely driven by economic coercion. In marxist concept of rights there is no place of universal theory of rights.
How can marxist international law theory position itself visa vis other critical legal traditions. It is presumably because the sources of production will be socialised and economic relations will be on cooperative basis. Mieville critically examines existing theories of international law and offers a compelling alternative marxist view. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. China mievilles brilliantly original book is an indispensable. Pdf china mieville and international law researchgate. Further references to this text will be given parenthetically by page number. Marxist international legal theory cannot be understood simply as an internal.
Human rights and the mediatization of international law. This monograph critically examines existing theories of international law and argues for an alternative marxist approach. Thus in the history of capitalist production the standardization of the working day takes the form of a struggle over the bounds of the working day a fight between the universal capitalist, i. China mieville between equal rights a marxist theory of international law 2005 free ebook download as pdf file. How can marxist international law theory position itself visavis other critical legal traditions. A general theory, and the 1922 treaty of rapallo between soviet russia and germany article in journal of the history of international law 192 january. This is reflected in an upsurge in scholarship dealing with international law s relationship to imperial power and its progressive potential. The role of politics, ideology, and history in the reconstruction of marxist legal theory are then considered with special attention to the virtues and limits of imbrication. Essays consider the relationship between marxism and critical approaches to international law, the legacy of soviet international legal theory, the bearing of marxism for the analysis of international trade law and human rights, and the significance for international legal enquiry of such marxist concepts as the commodity, praxis and exploitation. The result is that today the law and the constitution are seen by lawyers and politicians as guarantors of the independence and neutrality of the state, supposedly in contrast to feudal england or ancient athens. Marxist law introduction karl marx views the notion of marxist law from the following perspective, law, morality, religion, are to the proletariat so many bourgeois prejudices, behind which lurk in ambush just as many bourgeois interests. All citizens, in liberal democratic countries, are equally treated. China mieville, phd, international relations, london school of. In liberal theory of rights large amount of space has been devoted to the utility of equality before law.
A marxist theory of international law by china mieville. Between equal rights a marxist theory of international. Marxism and international law a contemporary analysis b s chimni changes in international law over the past two decades have made it an instrument for safeguarding transnational capital. Mieville critically examines existing theories of international law and offers a. The dissertation research was conducted under fred halliday, a left. The marxist theory of law and the construction of socialism. Respectful of the marxist classics, between equal rights is the most sophisticated left critique of international law available today as well as one of the most significant contributions to the theory and history of international law i have read.
And these rights are, in theory, enforceable by any individual acting through the courts. Mieville revisits the work of 1920s russian jurist e. It offers a guide for the lay reader into the central texts in the field. Pashukanis to develop a marxist theory of law along the lines of marxs treat. Between equal rights, like the three volumes of marxs capital that form its main theoretical infrastructure, does not, in fact, deal in any very explicit way with revolution. It is as the latter that between equal rights represents a real oasis in the desert for those of us teaching the law of nations, international relations, or diplomatic history. Mieville, the commodityform theory of international law. Pashukanis to develop a commodityform theory of international law. This book draws on pashukanis, critical legal studies and the history of international regulation to critique existing theories of international law. A marxist theory of international law historical materialism. China mieville between equal rights a marxist theory of.
Marxism and the rule of law michael mandel osgoode hall law school of york university. A marxist theory of international law, china mieville revisits the work of 1920s russian jurist e. Decrying the complicity of legal norms with the violence inflicted by empires and colonization, between equal rights weighs marxism against mercantile. China mieville draws on the pioneering jurisprudence of evgeny pashukanis. Between equal rights china mieville haymarket books po box 180165, chicago, il 60618. A marxist theory of international law historical materialism books haymarket books, by china mieville actually, book is actually a home window to the world.
Peter gowan, professor, international relations, london metropolitan university. A marxist theory of international law historical materialism books haymarket books, by china mieville. Marxism, international law, and political strategy. All about worldview karl marx views the notion of marxist law from the following perspective, law, morality, religion, are to the proletariat so many bourgeois prejudices, behind which lurk in ambush. Library of congress cataloginginpublication data miville, china between equal rights. A contemporary analysis article pdf available in economic and political weekly 346 february 1999 with 795 reads how we measure reads. Colonialism and domination matthew craven 1 see generally, a anghie imperialism, sovereignty and the making of international law c u p c a m bridge 2004. A marxist theory of international law historical materialism at. Marxist materialist theories relegate law to the ideological social superstructure and present law as an epiphenomenal and derivative tool harnessed for unequal, oppressive and ideological purposes. Historical materialism book series, issn 15701522 originally presented as the authors thesis doctoral dept.
May 04, 2017 the position occupied by law in capitalist society is contested by different strands of jurisprudential thought. A marxist theory of international law china mieville the german revolution 19171923 pierre broue about the series more than ten years after the collapse of the berlin wall and the disappearance of marxism as a supposed state ideology, a need for a serious and longterm marxist book publishing program has risen. A marxist theory of international law, was published in the uk in 2005 by brill in their historical materialism series, and in the united states in 2006 by haymarket books. But the marxist theory of revolution is logically grounded in the analysis of capitalism invented by marx and developed by pashukanis and mieville, among so many others. Pdf changes in international law over the past two decades have made it an instrument for safeguarding transnational capital. China mievilles brilliantly original book is an indispensable guide for anyone concerned with international law. This book critically examines existing theories of international law and makes the case for an alternative marxist approach. It raises the debate about law s role in a globalised world order to a completely new level. At another level, however, it tells the story of international law and its intellectual development from a marxist point of view.
A book version of his phd thesis, entitled between equal rights. The dissertation research was conducted under fred halliday, a leftwing intellectual who has spanned the bridge between straight academic work and intelligent public debate. A marxist theory of international law china mieville china mieville’s brilliantly original book is an indispensable guide for anyone concerned with international law. The spread and development of international law occurred on the basis of the spread and development of the capitalist mode of production. Pashukanis insights to the study of international lawbetween equal rights. Ernest mandel 192395 was the most influential exponent of marxist economic theory in the western world during the second half of the 20th century, and is best known for his masterful twovolume work marxist economic theory 1962 and his brilliant late capitalism 1972. A marxist theory of international law by china mieville, 9781931859332, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. The theory serves as a valuable and instructive counterpoint to influential currents in international legal scholarship. We may thus ask ourselves whether marxs strong and coherent refusal to accept a theory of social justice necessarily implies the refusal of a theory of rights, in particular human rights. But it appears that marxism is still very much alive, and that it has deeply influenced a direct line of contemporary legal thinkers, who have adopted some of its ideas or picked up some aspects of this radical theory. International judicial activism and the commodityform theory. At the heart of the theories in this chapter is social stratification by class and power, and they are the most politicized of all criminological theories. For the sake of convenience i will speak of cases and doctrine as.
556 723 382 1303 557 841 437 1489 1113 1386 1159 352 964 684 1560 378 385 104 1649 389 353 775 175 634 730 1400 1029 695 887 1658 220 624 1642 47 1231 1413 320 1385 711 940 70 716 1022 1274